Should the government provide free tertiary education?
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@9F8GB9BOpportunities2yrs2Y
The last year of the education should be free
Yes. But entry requirements should be much higher.
@9DGDCMZ2yrs2Y
Help young people study without creating themselves huge dept which puts them off, they are the future tax payers
@9DF3F8F2yrs2Y
No. People are attending university to then perform menial tasks and not use their degrees. It is a privilege, not a right, to attend university. There are plenty of other opportunities to unskill.
@9D5VZSK2yrs2Y
Only the last year of your degree or qualification should be free
@9KL2Z831yr1Y
If the students deserve it and are smart enough to get in there normally and increase the amount of free collage
@9G6KVPJ1yr1Y
No, but the current first year free system has been effective in getting people that otherwise would not have gone on to further study into tertiary environments and then gives them a bit of time to arrange payment plans for the following years
@9G6KSN91yr1Y
Selected courses should receive fee subsidies (above what they're already getting) to encourage people into fields where we have a shortage of qualified professionals, like health. Other courses should remain as they are.
@9G6J2QD1yr1Y
All persons should be eligible for funding but only reimbursed based on attendance and achieving the intended qualification.
@9G5SSW61yr1Y
No, but student allowance should not be based on parents wages. A lot of students pay for uni themselves with assistance from their parents
@9G3BQZB1yr1Y
I think it should be discounted or refunded for careers that are need in this country once qualified so education is completed
@9G393661yr1Y
Free for relevant practical courses - not plilosphy or arts type degrees. Universities need to tighten their belts and decrease fees as they are frivalous.
@9FYTGYQ1yr1Y
Yes 100%, with the cost of living as high as it is and students needing to study and work in order to earn enough in life to literally just survive. The least the government can do now is to provide if not all free tertiary education, then at least the first two years of it free.
Yes in sectors that are crying out for staff. Eg. nursing and teaching. Don’t have the first year free, rather reimburse the first year when they graduate
I believe that the tertiary education should be discounted depending on what the nation needs.
While we are lacking in nurses and doctors, there should be a government incentive for those fields.
It is about doing what is good for the country, not for individuals.
Pay the 2nd year after student has passed the first year and are more committed and have experienced a year paying their own way as they have to now after the first year
Maybe last year free instead of first year of study. Consideration of reverting back to if excellence or merit endorsed in NCEA then a certain amount of money is given to each year of study
Yes, but only uponachievement of the qualification.
only if the degree/course/masters ect is completed
@9FP926J1yr1Y
first year free should stay
First year free fees are good, as long as its equal across the board. Free for everyone. Noone gets any other exceptions. Doctor and nurse and care home assistants should get free training, or paid to train on the job.
No, maybe subsidise if you pass the qualification
Last year should be with contract to stay in nz for 5 years
@9FL9VR9 2yrs2Y
Yes, but introduce merit-based entrance tests
Fees free should be on completion of complete programme to discourage individuals pulling out without completion.
@9FJSWLLOpportunities2yrs2Y
No, but free for jobs where we have a deficit and need more people in those jobs
Yes but anyone who does not graduate will be required to pay it back
Maintain first year fees free
no, there should be more aid from the government but not free tuition
yes if the course started is finished, if a person does not finish then they must pay the full amount, unless obviously a decent reason for not reason, eg illness
No, first-year free is a good policy but to make tertiary education free we must balance our national deficit and ultimately base subsidies on family income.
Yes but only in areas where we need the skills with bonding
@9FDVBMH2yrs2Y
Yes, but only final year of study
Yes, but it should come with expectations for attendance, engagement and completion and require repayment if these are not met (excluding exceptional circumstances)
@9FDR5C42yrs2Y
Fees free for last year of tertiary education
Yes but subsided for the last year of study and the degree must be completed
Yes. In areas where we as country have a need (medical, education, etc) the courses could be funded or free but have a mandatory time that the they most then work is NZ.
Yes, but only for in need occupations such as doctors and nurses
Tertiary Education for those wanting to become medical professionals/teachers should be treated as apprenticeships - so students are still able to gain an income while studying
Yes, but repaid if student drops out or doesn't pass
@9F9DVCL2yrs2Y
Yes but students must pay it back if they leave NZ to work in another country permanently within 5 years of graduation
Yes - but they must pass each year
if someone qualifies as a doctor or nurse, wipe their fess if they stay in NZ for 3 years
No but with a solid view to fully funding bright lower income students with good grades.
Yes but only for financially struggling students without jobs or first years.
Free final year, not first year.
@9F5RQ9X2yrs2Y
A refund if first year fees when students pass their year. Also free could be an indentured approach to hold them to work in nz
@9F5N3HN2yrs2Y
Yes , but in exchange students should have to serve in New Zealand for a number of years
First year pay and then less as you pass through
@9F4NNWFOpportunities2yrs2Y
Based on grades eg if you fail you have to pay but if you do well government pays for it or subsidizes it. But also tutor etc availablr to help people succeed. Maybe pay all costs eg Living costs etc perhaps for educatuon for roles hat are on our immigration list. Eg for roles we are in need of as a country.
@9F3JWTH2yrs2Y
Yes if you have excellent grades at High School and end up graduating your degree at uni
@9F3H5MX2yrs2Y
No, but reduce the costs students are required to pay. And have the government cover necessary costs
@9F238KQ2yrs2Y
Yes, for essential service feeding areas. I.e. Nursing
@9DZ76Y5Opportunities2yrs2Y
Yes for skill shortage qualifications
Yes but for those who already hold a degree and want to further their education
@9DY6WXGOpportunities2yrs2Y
Only for skill shortage areas
No, not until we balance our national deficit. Further, add limit e.g only first degree free otherwise risk exploitation of free study.
Yes, but only if there is an agreement that the person will stay in NZ for at least 5 years following graduation
Free for target areas such as nursing or teaching
@9DWFL5B2yrs2Y
No, but everyone should get allowance
@9DW99GK2yrs2Y
Yes, but as a final year payment for actually completing the study, not a first year.
@9DW8QS42yrs2Y
Yes, provided they complete the qualifications
@9DVNT8X2yrs2Y
Yes, but only provided if they pass the paper.
When degree completed then government should pay back 1/2 or all the fees
@9DT8TLZ2yrs2Y
Yes, for needed professions ie medicine, teaching
@9DT7ZYZ2yrs2Y
Partly, they should be subsidised e.g. fees free for 1/2 years
@9DSXQNWOpportunities2yrs2Y
Yes, but only for certain courses which will lead to jobs we need more of e.g. Teaching, medical
Yes, But only after the student has completed their qualification, can they be eligible for 1 year back pay into their student loan OR have their full tuition paid, but they must stay in NZ for 5 years post study.
@9DSR5DR2yrs2Y
The government should partially pay
@9DS2MDS2yrs2Y
Offer free tuition to the final year students as first year students often have tons of scholarship options they can apply for.
@9DRCX3B2yrs2Y
Yes but limited to passing course and limited time
@9DPQCWX2yrs2Y
It should be means tested to a real ent level
Student allowance threshold needs to increase
@9DP98FZ2yrs2Y
Yes but only for certain courses and is free at the completion of study
@9DNF5M72yrs2Y
Free for Apprentices only
@9DMSH5C2yrs2Y
Yes and student loan forgiveness should be considered for exceptional circumstances such as for people who, within a certain time frame post graduating, develop chronic illnesses/disabilities/injuries that prevent them from being able to work.
@9DMMBMD2yrs2Y
Yes, for high demand professions such as doctors. Students should pay there own way, and have there student loads cleared upon graduation.
@9DK4TDV2yrs2Y
subsidised if pass each year
@9DHF7VV2yrs2Y
Second year free, not first year as people drop out
@9DG6PJ22yrs2Y
No but if there is a benefit should be same for all.
@9DFDKNP2yrs2Y
Yes but only if you complete your degree and work in NZ for a number of yrs.
@9DFC6KW2yrs2Y
Only for jobs with staff shortages such as nurses and drs
@9DF24ZD2yrs2Y
No, and student allowance eligibility should not be based on parental income
@9DCBVH52yrs2Y
Tuition costs are good in comparison to other countries, but first year free should stay to incentivise university education
Yes, but only for selected subjects and on the proviso that they work here afterward
@9D9GD572yrs2Y
@9D9DG7XOpportunities2yrs2Y
Yes but for the academic pathway you need to have achieved to a reasonable standard. Less places but free basically.
@9D945QZ2yrs2Y
Undergraduate should incur fees. Postgraduate should be free.
Yes, but scaled upwards by 1/4 every year towards qualification completion
Should target specific courses where there is skill shortage
@9D8FVKF2yrs2Y
No, but the final year is free
Free for students with appropriate aptitude
To some qualifications like nursing
@9D78KQN2yrs2Y
Free for the FIRST YEAR of tertiary education
@9D6KQ5GOpportunities2yrs2Y
Yes, but it should be pro rata’d on excellent performance/hard work
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...