Should the government provide free tertiary education?
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@9F8GB9BOpportunities2yrs2Y
The last year of the education should be free
Yes. But entry requirements should be much higher.
Yes to qualifications that yield an 80%+ chance to secure a professional career.
@9DYVGHW2yrs2Y
I agree with the firs year free and perhaps lowering tuition costs across the board. More assistance for those doing courses in skills shortage areas such as a training wage or similar for those doing nursing, midwifing, or similar courses that prevent the ability to have a steady job during study (similar to a trades apprentice or hair dressing etc)
@9DGDCMZ2yrs2Y
Help young people study without creating themselves huge dept which puts them off, they are the future tax payers
@9DF3F8F2yrs2Y
No. People are attending university to then perform menial tasks and not use their degrees. It is a privilege, not a right, to attend university. There are plenty of other opportunities to unskill.
@9D63ZYTOpportunities2yrs2Y
Yes, but only for qualifications supporting jobs on the skills shortage lists
@9D5VZSK2yrs2Y
Only the last year of your degree or qualification should be free
@9RWHKMK8mos8MO
No, education is barely valued in NZ as it is, and this will encourage people going to university to "have a laugh". Improve education in NZ first, then focus on this.
@9KL2Z831yr1Y
If the students deserve it and are smart enough to get in there normally and increase the amount of free collage
@9G6PNBH1yr1Y
Yes as long as students commit to giving back to the country that has allowed them to study for free
@9G6KVPJ1yr1Y
No, but the current first year free system has been effective in getting people that otherwise would not have gone on to further study into tertiary environments and then gives them a bit of time to arrange payment plans for the following years
@9G6KSN91yr1Y
Selected courses should receive fee subsidies (above what they're already getting) to encourage people into fields where we have a shortage of qualified professionals, like health. Other courses should remain as they are.
@9G6J2QD1yr1Y
All persons should be eligible for funding but only reimbursed based on attendance and achieving the intended qualification.
@9G5X2RQ1yr1Y
Yes but with criteria - e.g. free nursing degree on the provision you complete a minimum of 10 years working in NZ in a nursing type role. If you leave NZ to work overseas you will be liable to pay back your education.
@9G5WJSH1yr1Y
Tertiary education should not be free, but there should be scholarships for people with excellent grades and CV, irrespective of family income.
@9G5TWHW1yr1Y
Essential services - such as medical/nursing and teaching should have tuition fees - and the fees are proportionally reimbursed through a bonding scheme over a 7 year period.ie, the costs are wiped.
@9G5SSW61yr1Y
No, but student allowance should not be based on parents wages. A lot of students pay for uni themselves with assistance from their parents
@9G48SVW1yr1Y
No but the system of allowances should be made fairer, get rid of means testing parents incomes. give all students the equivalent of the dole to live
@9G3BQZB1yr1Y
I think it should be discounted or refunded for careers that are need in this country once qualified so education is completed
@9G393661yr1Y
Free for relevant practical courses - not plilosphy or arts type degrees. Universities need to tighten their belts and decrease fees as they are frivalous.
@9G38SRF1yr1Y
Yes, but only if you complete the degree. Hence if you start other degrees without finishing, those course costs are not free
@9G2VHHM1yr1Y
Change the first year free, to the last year free, then move to 2nd year free, make it progressive. If you are committed to your study then subsidise it. Also, in areas where there is greater need, then make it free, nursing for example.
@9G286P31yr1Y
Yes for areas with high need for graduates, on the proviso that the graduate works in NZ for a period afterwards to qualify
@9FYTGYQ1yr1Y
Yes 100%, with the cost of living as high as it is and students needing to study and work in order to earn enough in life to literally just survive. The least the government can do now is to provide if not all free tertiary education, then at least the first two years of it free.
@9FYS7DR1yr1Y
Do the last year free, not the first, that way it's for those who will actually finish their degrees
@9FYGW761yr1Y
Nurses, doctors, teachers and other essential workers should have their tuition fees wiped if they work for three years in NZ after graduating.
Yes Children should be paid in vouchers to go to school after the age of 13 to cover buses, books, outdoor activities, school related exercises
subsidising costs of tertiary education is important and not just based on a family income. Some students do not align themselves with their families and some families hide their wealth in trusts.
Yes. But I think that universities are already in financial trouble. So, I am unsure if 100% free education will be financially viable
Yes, but the criteria to get FREE education should be met and the range of courses that offer FREE education should be vetted and needed in New Zealand. Only to avoid people entering education on useless degrees.
Yes in sectors that are crying out for staff. Eg. nursing and teaching. Don’t have the first year free, rather reimburse the first year when they graduate
I believe that the tertiary education should be discounted depending on what the nation needs.
While we are lacking in nurses and doctors, there should be a government incentive for those fields.
It is about doing what is good for the country, not for individuals.
Support or partial funding for relevant tuition that serves to add value in NZ and for a career. Eg health, engineering, teaching (not languages, art, sport, history, religion, dramatics)
Pay the 2nd year after student has passed the first year and are more committed and have experienced a year paying their own way as they have to now after the first year
No, keep the current 1 year of free tertiary education, but change it to the final year rather than the first
@9FTBDZY1yr1Y
Yes with a bond to stay in New zealand for same number of years as education takes or pay back costs
Maybe last year free instead of first year of study. Consideration of reverting back to if excellence or merit endorsed in NCEA then a certain amount of money is given to each year of study
Yes, but only uponachievement of the qualification.
only if the degree/course/masters ect is completed
@9FPG44R1yr1Y
Yes, subsidised free education for NZ citizens. Accommodation and Enrolment and text book and material fees to be paid by students.
@9FP926J1yr1Y
first year free should stay
@9FNHTL51yr1Y
No we can't afford it. A grant system would be helpful
@9FN85LZ1yr1Y
Yes, to an extent. Government should provide incentivised learning for last year graduates. E.g. fees free for last year of degree. And/Or gradually increased subsided learning costs per year and paid placement after study with free living costs for jobs taken in New Zealand. Eligible students for this incentive will have both a degree conpleted in nz education system and have signed job contract within 5 years of completing their degree.
First year free fees are good, as long as its equal across the board. Free for everyone. Noone gets any other exceptions. Doctor and nurse and care home assistants should get free training, or paid to train on the job.
@9FN5HPJ1yr1Y
would support targeted funding for targeted areas of growth, but not blanket 'free tertiary education' across the board
No, but have a base level covered free
No, maybe subsidise if you pass the qualification
@9FMD9XZ1yr1Y
Yes, as long as students finish with a qualification
Last year should be with contract to stay in nz for 5 years
@9FLB8F32yrs2Y
Yes, but they should only provide a discount / removal of fees upon completion of the degree.
@9FL9VR9 2yrs2Y
Yes, but introduce merit-based entrance tests
I believe education should be free but trades, polytechnic and other kinds of apprenticeships should be pushed just as hard
No but should have universal student allowance and increase course related costs
Fees free should be on completion of complete programme to discourage individuals pulling out without completion.
@9FK6V3D2yrs2Y
Yes if the student passes
@9FJSWLLOpportunities2yrs2Y
No, but free for jobs where we have a deficit and need more people in those jobs
@9FJLWNT2yrs2Y
Yes but anyone who does not graduate will be required to pay it back
@9FHS4ZS2yrs2Y
Essential vocational courses should be free
Maintain first year fees free
Only for students who pass their studies to a high merit
no, there should be more aid from the government but not free tuition
yes if the course started is finished, if a person does not finish then they must pay the full amount, unless obviously a decent reason for not reason, eg illness
@9FGP6RFOpportunities2yrs2Y
Yes, the last year of tertiary education should be free, and more scholarships for less-fortunate with excellent grades.
Yes but not for the first year, they should reward the students that succeed not waste money on the ones that go for the first year because its free then not carry on after that.
No, first-year free is a good policy but to make tertiary education free we must balance our national deficit and ultimately base subsidies on family income.
It should be free for certain employees but they should be bonded for the period it would be paid for
@9FFVYH7DemocracyNZ2yrs2Y
No, final year of university should be free instead of first
Incentive based approch to tertiary education: Tuition fees should be reimbursed if you finish your studies/degree
Current up front fees with partial rebate on successful completion of course.
Yes but only in areas where we need the skills with bonding
@9FDVBMH2yrs2Y
Yes, but only final year of study
Yes, but it should come with expectations for attendance, engagement and completion and require repayment if these are not met (excluding exceptional circumstances)
@9FDR5C42yrs2Y
Fees free for last year of tertiary education
Yes but subsided for the last year of study and the degree must be completed
Tuition should be partly funded and student allowance should be available to all students living in a city with a higher cost of living
@9FCH6R62yrs2Y
Yes but only for people studying courses that qualify people into skilled areas where resources are low in NZ (e.g doctors, nurses, teachers etc)
Yes. In areas where we as country have a need (medical, education, etc) the courses could be funded or free but have a mandatory time that the they most then work is NZ.
The government should fund certain essential courses e.g STEM subjects
Yes, but only for in need occupations such as doctors and nurses
Tertiary Education for those wanting to become medical professionals/teachers should be treated as apprenticeships - so students are still able to gain an income while studying
@9FBWBZZ2yrs2Y
Reduced tertiary fees More emphasis on trades and practical work skill training
Yes, but with a cap on the amount of free training per individual irrespective of level of study.
Yes, in a means tested way
Yes, but repaid if student drops out or doesn't pass
@9FB4JMH2yrs2Y
Yes, Tertiary tuition should be free for certain courses but the student should be required to pay if they are required to resit a paper. Public funding should also be limited to one course of study to prevent people becoming career students. For courses such as medicine and law there should be a requirement to give back some time within New Zealand before being able to take their skills offshore.
@9F9G444Opportunities2yrs2Y
Yes, but also wipe current student loans.
Yes as long as the education programmes funded are based on science/fact, critical thinking and encourages open debate and not simply ideological indoctrination.
@9F9DVCL2yrs2Y
Yes but students must pay it back if they leave NZ to work in another country permanently within 5 years of graduation
Yes - but they must pass each year
if someone qualifies as a doctor or nurse, wipe their fess if they stay in NZ for 3 years
No but with a solid view to fully funding bright lower income students with good grades.
Yes to select professions and then bond them to work in the country
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...