Private prisons are incarceration centers that are run by a for-profit company instead of a government agency. The companies that operate private prisons are paid a per-diem or monthly rate for each prisoner they keep in their facilities. In 2018 10% of prisoners in New Zealand were housed in private prisons. Opponents of private prisons argue that incarceration is a social responsibility and that entrusting it to for-profit companies is inhumane. Proponents argue that prisons run by private companies are consistently more cost effective than those run by government agencies.
@8GDSK5D4yrs4Y
Doesn’t matter who as long as the jobs done properly
@8D56KYS4yrs4Y
@9J78RN2 3mos3MO
Over process of prison and the court over government lawful behavior against and trespass in the built-in
@9HK9YD6 5mos5MO
The right wings running for prisoners by the warrant to arrested by police and connection officers funds
@9H6KYYJ5mos5MO
Yes, but only in some areas of the country, and they should be strictly regulated to prevent mismanagement and corruption
@9G6PNBH7mos7MO
It shouldn’t matter who runs our prisons but ensuring its with a NZ life style focus, added with a maori lens. The audit system needs to uphold or prisons accoubtable
@9G27TYV7mos7MO
Yes, but contracts can’t be built around costs. As the govt doesn’t worry about costs on the current prison system
@9FFNQFX7mos7MO
I agree with both the 4th and 5th options although they contradict
@9FDNYLC7mos7MO
Yes, and families of inmate should have to pay for your stay. No money coming in no food, blankets etc. Your sentence and welfair is not an issue of law-abiding citizens.
No, and we should work towards prison abolition
it could make a lot of people lose their jobs if a private company takes over
No, and we should be working towards doing away with Prisons, and they should only be for the worst kinds of criminals.
Yes, but give all power to the contractors, its prison not a hotel
@9F7J9CTOpportunities8mos8MO
No, but rehabilitation facilities for violent crimes etc could be to reduce recidivism
@9F7H96NNew Zealand First8mos8MO
No, although potentially more effective, private prisons may sacrifice care quality for profit
they should not have to do that just for prisoners i think they are quite cappaple of looking and respecting them selfs and its just wrong for the guards and etc. to treat them diffrently when they are simple humans just like us they are not diffrent
If it lowers tax then yes
What would be more relevant is coming to a conclusion of a working system of care and most importantly rehabilitation, Look at a country that has got it right and learn from them. Private or not
I don't really understand this
Prison should be focused on rehabilitation of inmates with a focus on helping them with their mental health and becoming safe enough to potentially be back in civilisation
Yes, but have publicly owned prisons for competition and accountability standards.
@9DYWGBW8mos8MO
Don't have much knowledge on this to comment
No, but more prisons are needed as well as a harder stance on crime
they need to be run alongside the government so they do not ruin nz image
@9DQJZ7J8mos8MO
As long as someone can run a prison well, and keep them in check, it doesn't matter.
@9DQJWV28mos8MO
Yes, only if private prisons still treat the people serving with care and not in it for the money.
Yes, only if the company is well vetted and monitored for accountability.
@9DPF83L8mos8MO
No, prisons shouldn't make profits
@9DPF35X8mos8MO
Life sentence should be re introduced for sex offenders, Murderers etc
@9DKD3TD8mos8MO
More Maori focused units in prisons and more of a focus on rehabilitation like in the Netherlands no matter who runs the prisons.
@9DF9QR98mos8MO
Yes, but they should be held to the same or greater standards as public prisons and any related policy must have a sunset clause specifying that after a given amount of time, the government will analyze the quality of the private prisons and if there is a statistical increase in the number of incidents and/or degradation in the quality of prison functions it must at the very least suspended or abolished.
@9DF7VFX8mos8MO
No keep it as the police
@9DDG52P8mos8MO
No becuase the prisons need to be public so family can vist that is one of the key ways they change.
@9DD5BB28mos8MO
We should be focusing more on rehabilitating these people
Abolish prisons entirely
@9DCXRJJ8mos8MO
If they can run them cheaper than the government
@9DCCQHCOpportunities8mos8MO
No. Justice should not be outsourced under any circumstances.
@9DBKWTR8mos8MO
yes, because if private companys run the prisons they may bring in money from overseas and we would have to pay less of our money towards prisons
@9DB574C8mos8MO
Yes, however police need to be able to access and regulate to prevent mismanagement and corruption
@9D9WBBX9mos9MO
@9D6LXY49mos9MO
Yes, incentivise them if they decrease reoffending rates
@9CHMF4Z10mos10MO
It depends on the quality of care for prisoners. Prisoners are different from elderly care although they have a right to human rights in ways that doesnt cause conflict with their sentencing.
Which ever service provides knowledge and education should be suitable for where prisoners are being sent.
Example would be if someone was sentenced to life in prison. Instead of living with their mistakes they should be educated in a healthy way. That way if once they gain enough courage to change their perception they would be able to advocate against regrettable mistakes for the remainder of their life sentence without feeling drained and forgotten to society.
Every civillian has an opinion. Those who are oppressed become villains. And every villain has a back ground story for us to understand how things can be avoided.
@8DR3FBT4yrs4Y
well I think that they shouldn't because they might not know how to control the prison
@8DC58GJ4yrs4Y
@8CPH6CH4yrs4Y
Officers can just run the prisons but no one is allowed to RUN someone they can run the place and manage the people but they have no right to RUN a person.
@8CCLKDF4yrs4Y
Private prisons should hire their own staff then approved by the movement in their choices.
@8C9PQZ24yrs4Y
No, but put more into senior living.
@9FZXW5Q7mos7MO
I think they should be privatized but the prisoners should have to do government manual labor jobs for free. ( i.e. land clearing. Rubbish pick up)as they still have to pay the prison to keep prisoners. And just means the prisoners are contributing to getting feed, showered and a bed over there head instead of getting a free ride
Have offenders carry out work under strict supervision until their equivalent prison period has ended - make offenders work/give back the money they are costing taxpayers if taxpayers are having to pay to keep them in prison.
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...