Should New Zealand increase or decrease military spending?
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political party:
Political theme:
Electorate:
Electorate:
Postcode:
Don’t know how much is being spent
@9DGFBRJ1yr1Y
Increase surrounding climate change and related changes to our strategic environment
@9TDLWQZ2mos2MO
They don't need extra money because we are never under attack but we shouldn't take money away incase there is an attack
@9RDDX4TNew Zealand First4mos4MO
when our military cargo planes the Hercules/hercs are 50 years old and we denied ourselves access to jets that could of helped and still can help with the countries defences and most of our planes are from the 90's or earlier
@9Q37867New Conservative5mos5MO
2% of GDP 48% police deparment, 30% Nuclearand biological Research, 10% food for the rich, and the rest to line the pockets of the rich
@9L9R4MQ 8mos8MO
Increase, and make our youth more patriotic/nationalistic to new zealand whether they are european or maori/islander
I think we should decrease the spending because we are not in any trouble and I don't think that any country will attack us.
@9DHHD6F1yr1Y
NZ has virtually no capability to defend itself and is too reliant on other countries. If we spent more on DEFENCE this could also offer people careers they otherwise wouldn't have access to.
@9DHBC9C1yr1Y
Increase a lot so that if I join the air force I get to fly planes
@9DGGDY61yr1Y
Uneducated in this to give an informed decision
@9DGCHBT1yr1Y
navy should have many small bases with coastal boats , torpedo and minigun armed. air force should have fast deploy heavily armed jets for coastal protection . army should specialize in coastal defense and guerilla warfare
@9DG9SZR1yr1Y
Remain the same but extra careful on where the money goes.
@9DDN8391yr1Y
Increase, and allow children under the age of 13 to join the millitary
@9DDDTXM1yr1Y
Yes but only for military aid of other countries
@9DBLKS91yr1Y
Increase but to buy more NZ required equipment and pay for better wages, more NZ based staff and training for deployment within New Zealand only or to assist in pacific nations non military rescue.
Stop paying higher ranking officials so much and wasting money on frivolous spending within military
Increase, but the current military spending should be investigated and made more efficient
@9D8K7SH1yr1Y
Only if it is to better our NZ defence if they were to be a war against us.
Yes, but only for natural disaster response
@9D89C771yr1Y
Reform from a military force into a civil defence force
Add funding to support our military in responding to natural disasters at hom
Spending should reflect the needs of our defence services especially as it relates to maintenance of equipment and staffing in order to provide peacekeeping and emergency relief, support of allies, and to ensure they can respond appropriately in a time of crisis
Yes, but not on WMD. #staynuclearfree
Increase but as a way to upskill youth and help them get into the workforce with out student loans
Decrease, fighting in international wars but increase for essential country service such as the emergency landing site in Ohakea
@9FYFYHM1yr1Y
it depends on the current rate of spending at that does not seem to be something clearly transparent or somewhat publically made avaliable "or known of to be"
Maintain current spending, ensure money is spent on peacekeeping, environmental security, foreign aid/disaster relief.
@9FQB2721yr1Y
As an industry the trains and supports growth of a work force, yes.
@9FPG44R1yr1Y
Increase, to allow 2 year compulsory training of NZers, provision of material resources, weapons and naval, army and airforce equipment to support this and
Increase for training of high skilled people and retain them for nz sush as for health and education.
@9FNDKFS1yr1Y
Decrease. Let the 'special interest groups' fund their own wars.
Yes, but military activity should be limited to relief, peacekeeping and fishery protection roles
We should combine spending with Australia and create a defending force.
No thought on the issue or matter.
@9FKCQGG1yr1Y
Peace keeping and defense only.
@9FJY7Z51yr1Y
Increase only if used for the protection of our own people in emergencies such as floods/hurricanes; decrease for warfare
@9FJHV7ZNew Conservative 1yr1Y
Increase: combine all groups, coast guards, military, airforce, navy etc, into one group and work together
We should only have a navy as we are a small island, but have new boats and equipment, with the coast guard as a support to the navy.
Increase but specifically to deal with personnel issues
Pay Australia to defend us with their military
@9FFPMFV1yr1Y
i think its good how it is
depends on what necessary
About the same or less but use for civil emergencies not war.
Increase the budget on education and healthcare instead of military.
Increase, but only because global-geopolitics is going to become more turbulent in the future.
Increase where necessary to ensure we can patrol and protect our borders and also to ensure military help for emergencies
Dependent on world hostilities
Complex and circumstantial
The military should be disbanded and abolished
We should become neutral and have armed forces for aid or fisheries protection only
Increase, but target their activities to more local needs to help fill the gaps in our policing.
@9F9CXWB1yr1Y
Don’t care / know what that means
If it strengthens the military then increase
If it’ll strengthen the military then increase
@9F86C5D1yr1Y
Increase, but we should be using our militaries skills more locally during emergencies. Peacekeeping to free up our police, clean up and construction coordination
Decrease, put the funds into a civil defence force.
Yes. For responding to disasters.
yes when appropriate, when needed yes.
Not enough knowledge to have a stance
Increase but make them more prevalent when community's are in destress they are deployed immediately.
Increase to improve protection of our ocean fisheries.
@9F4TY441yr1Y
We should focus on protecting our coastal borders increasing Naval capacity, fishing grounds and maintain relations with 5 eyes network providing humanitarian support as needed.
@9F3S3341yr1Y
New zealand should be de-militarized and funds repurposed into education and health.
Increase for domestic projects and aid-rendering capabilities
@9DY49VP1yr1Y
It’s ok to have the same spending but Should not get involved in Europe’s wars - should be protecting our interests in the pacific
Uncertain, I'm not familiar with the current spending.
There should be less fixation on arbitrary spending and instead restructure how we view the military with resources distributed accordingly. This includes the end of imperialist behaviour and instead a shift towards defence and peacekeeping when possible.
New Zealand should spend as much as is necessary to maintain staff and hardware required for ally support and national defence.
Yes, but we should fixate less on surface-level spending and instead look towards restructuring our military relations. A functional military service should end imperial influence and focus on sufficiency while benefitting the lives of civilians and our allies in the Pacific.
To patrol our waters and on peacekeeping operations only
@9DVC74K1yr1Y
Become a marine based elite fighting force.
@9DT6M4H1yr1Y
Dissolve military into more policing and civil works
Any school leavers who do not have a job to go to, or a training institute, should be required to join the military for life skills and training, thus the government will need to spend more in investing in our youth. This should be cost effective
@9DSPRKW1yr1Y
make is so that we have enough force to defend if something actually happens but no massive spend
@9DSL7JF1yr1Y
Increase, but only with the focus on disaster and emergency response, not armed conflict.
@9DRZX7V1yr1Y
NZ is most effective in sigint, (signal intelligence) invest there instead
@9DRYWK91yr1Y
I know nothing about this can’t comment but maybe stay the same because we don’t have military threat there are better things to spend it on
@9DRY7CM1yr1Y
Create a version of the US system with a “pentagon” like organization that allows you to use tax payer dollars to support high tech industry so that you can compete in the highest and fastest growing markets in the world. This illusion is called the military industrial complex but it’s really not for military spending it’s a guise to use the populations taxes to fund high tech industries.
@9DRVDPJ1yr1Y
I'm unsure of the amount spent
@9DRSL561yr1Y
I believe it should be increased but only after they have figured out a better long-term plan for our military. Personally i feel we should be investing in a far better navy or even coast guard. It would be very hard for most countries to even attempt to invade if we had sea power because we're so far from anywhere that they'd have a lot of difficulty with logistics.
@9DQZD5B1yr1Y
I'd have no idea what they need or are required for
Yes, by a lot. We need armoured vehicles (e.g. main battle tanks, armoured fighting vehicles), artillery (e.g. HIMARS multiple rocket launcher system), air defence systems (e.g. Patriot missile defence), more powerful navy ships (e.g. more advanced frigates, destroyers and cruisers, as well as submarines), and of course we need fighter aircraft (e.g. F-35, F-15EX, F-16V, Eurofighter Typhoon, Dassault Rafale). Also allow nuclear-powered vessels such as ships and submarines. We also need more soldiers. Our current military is too weak and lags too far behind other OECD countries and our allies.… Read more
@9DQVM7V1yr1Y
Don't have enough info about this
@9DQVF6Z1yr1Y
Don’t know how much they spend
@9DQSVGR1yr1Y
Decrease Militarization while increasing humanitarian efforts.
@9DQR34K1yr1Y
we need to spend all money on our military including our air force, Navy, Army and we need nuks
Increase but only after the deficit is drastically reduced. Have sufficient resources ready for disposal in the event of a significant natural disaster.
We should be spending more on fixing issues with healthcare and poverty
@9DP4NFR1yr1Y
Formally abolish the military
Only for crisis response increase
@9DKQG5Y1yr1Y
Aslong as it goes towards a more supporting environment that encourages holistic health and reduces institutional bullying and toxic behavior
@9DK2MZ61yr1Y
Increase and bring in more training for Fire /Flood and other National disaster responses that
@9DHM5WT1yr1Y
After the length of time it take for our military to get into action after a natural disaster, I hate to thing what it would be like if we were invaded.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...